Read + Write + Report
Home | Start a blog | About Orble | FAQ | Blogs | Writers | Paid | My Orble | Login

Anime Review: Blue Submarine No. 6

February 25th 2009 13:35
DVD cover

In the near future, a pole shift has been initiated by madman Dr. Zorndyke, raising the sea level and killing billions. Now, humanity has a last chance against Zorndyke and his genetically engineered, sea-dwelling soldiers, an all-or-nothing strike against their base in Antarctica. But it will come down to two pilots of the Blue Submarine #6, one bent on revenge, the other just wanting an end.


Fleet Week concludes with a more well-known (and better) anime, Blue Submarine No. 6, best known for being a pioneer in the area of combining traditional hand-drawn animation with CGI.

Blue Submarine #6 is a definite case of style over substance, though not by much. The story requires seeing it a couple of times; it is practically guaranteed that you will not understand the ending the first time through (if you do, you’re smarter than I). However, the story is worth the effort, dealing with fundamental questions of what it is to be human and the importance of forgiveness.

Publicity poster for Blue Submarine #6
Hayami and Kino, with Mutio in the foreground


The two main characters make a classic team: the idealistic, talented, hot-headed youngster (who bears a suspicious resemblance to Noa Izumi of Patlabor) and the cooler, more experienced, and more pragmatic (or more cynical) oldster. Secondary characters, including Zorndyke and his engineered army, are fairly well-developed, although I would have liked to have seen more. There’s talk of a live-action remake, and it would be nice if that one fleshed out the characters a little better.

But, no matter what the complaints about the story or characters, the action in this flick makes it all worthwhile. Blue Submarine #6 has some of the best underwater combat scenes ever, and the jazzy soundtrack really works too.

For a first time effort, the blending of different styles works pretty well too, although the CGI gives the traditional animation a slightly crude feel by comparison.

Aside from the trail-blazing aspect, Blue Submarine #6 is justly infamous for its manner of release. I first saw it as a starving graduate student in the days of VHS, and having rented anime before, I was rather surprised to find only one half-hour episode per tape. This is normal in Japanese releases, but American releases almost always had two or three episodes per tape. It wouldn’t be a big deal, except that one episode of Blue Submarine #6 cost as much to rent as a two-hour movie or three episodes of another series. In the DVD release, Bandai did a very similar thing, putting four episodes on two double-sided discs, when the whole series could fit onto one regular disc with room to spare. To buyers, it makes no difference. The whole set prices at a very reasonable twenty dollars, although it is weird to buy a DVD set with just the equivalent of a movie on it. Renters, however, will be irritated at having to rent two (or possibly four) discs when the whole series should be on one.

And, in case anyone is confused, this is not the sequel to Blue Submarine No. 5. The name of the organization is Blue, the name of the submarine is No. 6, hence, Blue Submarine No. 6.

Screenshot from first episode
Submarine #6 in port

Extras: A whole disk-full, including staff interviews, additional scenes, mecha and character designs, and original trailers.

Great moments: Definitely the battle scenes. From the attack on the port in the first episode to the showdown with the Phantom Ship in the last, the military action is excellent.

Summary: Solid military drama with a sci-fi element. May require repeated viewings, but worth it. Grade: B plus

Age rating: 14 and up. Some of Zorndyke’s creations are female, and nude, at least from the waist up. There is an implied sexual assault on one of them as well, although the scene changes before it actually happens. Violence and death in a wartime context, with a little more actual bloodshed than is normal for submarine movies.
68
Vote
   


Anime Review: Silent Service

February 20th 2009 11:44
DVD cover

The Seabat, a nuclear submarine whose building was a joint project of the United States and Japan. Part of the US Navy, but with a Japanese crew, the captain has his own plans for the boat. Renaming it the Yamato, he declares the submarine to be an independent nation, and brings Japan and America to the brink of war.

It’s Fleet Week at Anime Bottle! The next three postings will be about animes with a naval theme, all centered around submarine action.

Based on a long-running manga, Silent Service is a solid, if jingoistic, military drama and recommended for navy and submarine buffs. The action is very nicely done, and the plot is complex and intriguing. The fight sequences, involving both submarines and surface ships, are fairly realistic, and interspersed with political jousting over the international incident that the hijacking of the Seabat has caused.

It’s in the actions of the characters that realism starts to break down. First of all, we’re asked to believe that an entire submarine crew would fake their deaths and abandon their families in order to keep the secret of Japan’s first nuclear submarine. Later, it’s revealed that at least a hundred American and Japanese naval officers and government officials know about the Seabat project. All those people know about the real truth about happened to those men who were thought to have in what appeared to be Japan’s worst maritime accident since WWII, and no one leaked, on purpose or accidentally? It’s a little hard to swallow.

The Americans in the movie are arrogant and hot-headed. The American naval officers are consistently over-confident in facing the rogue submarine, and the politicians are downright reckless. At one point in the film, the American President considers a full-scale invasion of Japan (over a submarine?). And in a scene or two, I couldn’t help but wonder if I saw just a touch of rascism. This is hardly the first anime to portray Americans as stereotypically ugly, but it is rarer among dramatic anime.

On the Japanese side, Silent Service is a Japanese nationalist’s wet dream. Not only do the Japanese finally stand up to the over-bearing Americans, the Yamato (named for the ancient name for the Japanese homeland) repeatedly humbles the US Seventh Fleet, going so far as to sink a number of ships, including the carrier USS Enterprise, coincidentally (?) bearing the same name as one of the most famous US aircraft carriers of the Pacific War.

Silent Silence also feels unfinished. It ends at a good stopping point, but leaves a lot of dangling threads. The reason for this is that the original OVA run was six episodes, the first two of which were cut together for the Silent Service movie, and the last four remain unavailable outside of Japan. I do hope that changes at some point, because even with the unrealistic characters, it is a compelling story. The story, the action, and the price ($10) make this worth getting.

Extras: Character profiles, with video clips from the movie. Kinda thin.

Great moments: The part where the captain of the Yamato plays Mozart very loudly, allowing the US ships to hear him, and then slowly lowers the volume as he moves towards the Americans, fooling them into thinking that he’s not moving. I tend to doubt that would actually work in real life, but it’s still a cool tactic.

Summary: Military-political drama with a good amount of action. Do not watch if you’re American and easily offended. Grade: B plus

Age rating: 13 and up. Some non-bloody violence and death in a war context.
52
Vote
   


Anime Review: Jin-Roh, the Wolf Brigade

February 13th 2009 03:53
Jin-Roh DVD

Ten years after World War II, Japan is caught between a totalitarian government and a growing urban insurgency. When Fuse, a recruit with the federal anti-terrorist unit, witnesses a girl blow herself up during a raid, he starts to have second thoughts about what he does, and has to decide whether to stay an obedient animal or live as a free man.

Jin-Roh is an excellent thriller with a lot of twists. No one is who they appear to be, including the main character. This movie is part of a much larger arc (the “Kerberos saga”) of films (all directed by the great Mamoru Oshii), radio dramas, and mangas set in an alternate Japan. Jin-Roh is the last in the series, but, being a prequel, it works as a stand-alone.

Fuse himself is a complex character, at a crossroads in his life that the incident with the young woman has suddenly revealed. As he tries to find out where he belongs, he evokes our sympathy, and keeps it even after he’s made his choice. Even he doesn’t know who he truly is until the end (and maybe not even then; the ending is rather ambiguous).

The story of Little Red Riding Hood (or Rottkapchen), which Fuse reads after it is given to him by the dead girl’s sister, fits very well into the story, symbolically, with Fuze filling the role of Little Red and the wolf both, depending on how you look at it.

The symbolism doesn’t stop with the Grimm fairy tale. Wolves, standing for what Fuse is trying to get away from, are prominent in the background in several scenes, and the German cars and guns used by both the Wolf Brigade and the Public Security Division evoke the fascist regime of WWII Germany.

Extras: None (you’d think they’d at least include trailers for the other movies in the series)

Great moments: Not a great moment exactly, but the lead-up to the finale is a chilling scene. As Fuse puts on the armored suit and readies his gun, he figuratively transforms into the wolf before our very eyes.

Summary: Intriguing, character-driven thriller. Grade: B plus

Age rating: 13 and up. No fan service, but some bloody violence.
48
Vote
   


Anime Review: Sol Bianca, the Legacy

February 10th 2009 12:17
Warning: I do usually try to avoid spoilers in my reviews, but this one may contain some.
First DVD cover
April and the Sol Bianca

April and her crew of space pirates are just trying to get along in this universe. They never asked for the Terra Forces to come after them, and they certainly didn’t ask for a stowaway. But their chosen course will take April, Jan, Feb, and June back to where it all started, the long-lost planet of Earth.

There’s a scene at the end of the first episode (it’s a six episode OVA) which pretty much sums up the series. The crew has just stolen the loot from an auction house and are escaping aboard the Sol Bianca. The authorities (the Terra Forces) are in pursuit, and the pirates turn and fight. One of the crew, June (the cute computer geek), links with the Sol Bianca and generates a building-sized hologram, of a woman with a bow and arrow, with the ship as the head of the arrow. The maiden fires the arrow, an energy blast fires, the Terran ship is crippled, and our heroines get away. It’s an absolutely gorgeous scene that makes almost no sense.

Sol Bianca is a beautiful anime to look at. The ship and character designs are wonderful, the music is perfect, and I really dig the Spanish cultural references in the language and architecture. But like the climactic scene of the first episode, it leaves a lot unexplained. Like any good dramatic anime, Sol Bianca sets up a number of questions. What happened to Earth? What happened to stowaway Mayo’s parents? How did the various crew members come to join April? What’s so special about the Sol Bianca and why is Admiral Gyunther so anxious to get his hands on it? But most of these questions are either not answered in a very satisfying way, or not answered at all.

Plotwise, Sol Bianca is kind of a mess. The first episode is a good setup for the series, and the next two are stand alone episodes that focus two of the characters. Both of these feel like filler; although the first explains something of June’s origin and the second humanizes Jan (the muscle of the crew), a real opportunity to show some background in that hour was lost in favor of some admittedly neat action scenes and some rather silly comedy scenes.

The last three eps form an arc, starting with Feb (the seductive one, and a great pilot besides) leaving the ship and ending with the whole crew on Earth. Again, this could have been done very well, with an hour and a half to wrap up the various plot threads, but then more threads are added until the situation in the final episode is almost incomprehensible. The power struggle within the Terra Forces was completely illogical, and it felt like the creators wanted a big spaceship battle, but not with Gyunther, so they introduce another admiral from out of nowhere, and make him the Bad Guy. But this admiral and Gyunther seem to want the same thing from the Sol Bianca, so why are they fighting? I can understand the temptation to make a complex plot, but Sol Bianca proves that sometimes, less is more. We do at least see what happened to the Earth, but the Sol Bianca’s role in its recovery is never explained.

And here’s a thought. If the Earth is damaged and needs to heal, maybe a good first step would be not to build a giant shield around the planet that blocks out sunlight. Just a thought.

In a short OVA like this, the temptation is to excuse the makers by saying they simply didn’t have enough time to properly flesh out the plot and characters. But that doesn’t fly here. There’s plenty of time, but too much is frittered away.

That being said, it is one of the prettiest animes I’ve ever seen. Even if plot holes bother you, I would recommend seeing this.

DVD set art
The crew of the Sol Bianca. From left: June, Feb, Mayo (seated), Jan, and April

Extras: Character and ship designs, music videos.

Summary: Beautiful series, but too many gaps in plot and too little character development. Grade: C plus.

Age Rating: 13 and up. Violence, some light fan service, a non-explicit sex scene.
65
Vote
   


Anime Review: Salaryman Kintaro

February 8th 2009 05:17
Salaryman Kintaro DVD cover
DVD cover showing Kintaro and Ryuta

Former biker gang leader and widower Yojima Kintaro is now just trying to go straight and be the best father he can to his young son. When he takes an office job at Yamato Construction, the Japanese business world is about to get its strangest salaryman ever.

[ Click here to read more ]
42
Vote
   


Anime Review: Hyper Doll

February 3rd 2009 12:23
DVD cover
Hyper Doll DVD cover

The Earth is in danger, until the Hyper Dolls appear! These two teenage girls will defend our planet with every ounce of their considerable strength, if they can stop bickering long enough, and if Akai, the one human who knows their secret, doesn’t accidentally blab!

[ Click here to read more ]
57
Vote
   


Anime Review: Karin

January 18th 2009 05:04
Karin, DVD 1 cover

Karin Maaka appears to be just another normal (if slightly klutzy) schoolgirl in Japan. But she’s actually a vampire, in a family of vampires, their true identity kept secret from humans. Karin is unusual even among her own kind, as she doesn’t suck blood, she makes it! When new student Kenta Usui transfers to her school, she discovers that he causes her blood-making problem to get ten times worse. On top of that, another new student turns out to be a vampire hunter with a special grudge against Karin’s family!

[ Click here to read more ]
58
Vote
   


Anime Review: Fake

January 11th 2009 05:09
Promotional Poster for Fake

When Dee goes on vacation with Ryo to England, he thinks this might be his big chance. He just didn’t plan on the serial killer who targets Japanese. Or the ghost, for that matter.

[ Click here to read more ]
55
Vote
   


Promo shot for YUA:No Mercy

In the second YUA special, Tokyo traffic cops Miyuki and Natsumi are temporarily transferred to L.A. But when Miyuki’s car is stolen by a car theft ring, all hell is going to break loose!

[ Click here to read more ]
49
Vote
   


Anime Review: 801 TTS Airbats

December 28th 2008 03:45
Welcome back, everyone! Hope you all had a nice Christmas, and that Santa left lots of anime and manga under the tree!

DVD cover
Cover of the DVD

[ Click here to read more ]
46
Vote
   


Review: Anime, Concept to Reality

December 23rd 2008 16:45
Anime: C to R DVD
DVD cover

Ever wanted to produce your own anime? Watch this documentary, and maybe you can! Using software available on the market today, artist Terrence Walker makes his own anime features, and takes you through the process in Anime: Concept to Reality.

[ Click here to read more ]
43
Vote
   


The Bubblegum Crisis review series concludes, and I saved the best for last.

BCG 2040 poster

[ Click here to read more ]
66
Vote
   


Anime Review: Bubblegum Crash

December 14th 2008 04:49
Bubblegum Crash poster

A year after the events of Bubblegum Crisis, Megalocity is peaceful, and the Knight Sabres are seemingly out of business. But just as Linna, Priss, Sylia, and Nene are on the verge of splitting up for good, a new threat raises its head.

[ Click here to read more ]
66
Vote
   


Anime Review: Bubblegum Crisis

December 12th 2008 02:29
Bubblegum Crisis DVD image
The Knight Sabers: Linna, Sylia, Priss, and Nene

In the metropolis of Megalocity, the Genom corporation rules. Using the robots known as “Boomers”, they achieve their goals by any means necessary. Only four women, the power-armored vigilantes known as the Knight Sabers, stand against them.

[ Click here to read more ]
77
Vote
   


Moderated by NoaIzumi
Copyright © 2012 On Topic Media PTY LTD. All Rights Reserved. Design by Vimu.com.
On Topic Media ZPages: Sydney |  Melbourne |  Brisbane |  London |  Birmingham |  Leeds     [ Advertise ] [ Contact Us ] [ Privacy Policy ]